
An \[\alpha \] particle passes rapidly through the exact centre of a hydrogen molecule, moving on a line perpendicular to the internuclear axis. The distance between the nuclei is \[b\] . Where on its path does the \[\alpha \] -particle experience the greatest force? Assume that the nuclei do not move much during the passage of the \[\alpha \] particle. Also neglect the electric field of the electrons in the molecule.
A. $\dfrac{b}{2}$
B. $\dfrac{b}{{2\sqrt 2 }}$
C. $\dfrac{b}{{\sqrt 2 }}$
D. None of these
Answer
164.4k+ views
Hint: To solve this question, we will first consider a point on the perpendicular bisector of the line joining the two hydrogen atoms. To find the force between the \[\alpha \] particle and the hydrogen atom, we will consider the \[\alpha \] particle at that point and write the expression of force. Now, we know that the condition to find the extreme value of a function whose first derivative is kept equal to zero. We will use this concept to get the value of the greatest force experienced by the \[\alpha \] particle.
Formula Used:
Force between two charges,
$F = k\dfrac{{{q_1}{q_2}}}{{{r^2}}}$
where ${q_1}\,\& \,{q_2}$ are the two charges and $r$ is the distance between them.
Also, $k = \dfrac{1}{{4\pi { \in _o}}}$
Quotient formula of differentiation,
$\dfrac{d}{{dx}}\left( {\dfrac{{f\left( x \right)}}{{g\left( x \right)}}} \right) = \dfrac{{f'\left( x \right)g\left( x \right) - f\left( x \right)g'\left( x \right)}}{{{{\left( {g\left( x \right)} \right)}^2}}}$
Complete step by step solution:
Given: Charge on a hydrogen atom, ${q_1} = e$
Charge on the \[\alpha \] particles, ${q_2} = 2e$
Distance between the nuclei \[ = b\]
Let $F$ be the force between the \[\alpha \] particle and the hydrogen atom. Draw a perpendicular bisector of the line joining the nuclei of the two hydrogen atoms. Consider a point $P$ on it at a distance \[x\] from the foot of the perpendicular.

From the diagram above we can see that the vertical components of the force $F$ cancel each other. Hence, the net force becomes,
${F_{net}} = 2F\cos \theta $
Where $\cos \theta = \dfrac{x}{{{{\left( {{x^2} + {{\left( {\dfrac{b}{2}} \right)}^2}} \right)}^{\dfrac{1}{2}}}}}$
(denominator is obtained using Pythagoras theorem in $\vartriangle AOP$ )
This implies,
\[{F_{net}} = 2F\dfrac{x}{{{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{1}{2}}}}}\] ...(1)
Also,
$F = k\dfrac{{{q_1}{q_2}}}{{{r^2}}}$
That is,
$F = k\dfrac{{\left( e \right)\left( {2e} \right)}}{{{{\left( {{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{1}{2}}}} \right)}^2}}} \\ $...(2)
Substituting equation (2) in equation (1), we get,
\[{F_{net}} = 2\left( {k\dfrac{{\left( e \right)\left( {2e} \right)}}{{{{\left( {{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{1}{2}}}} \right)}^2}}}} \right)\dfrac{x}{{{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{1}{2}}}}} \\ \]
Simplifying this, we get,
\[{F_{net}} = \dfrac{{4kx{e^2}}}{{{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{3}{2}}}}}\]
Now, we know that the condition of extremum is: $\dfrac{{d{F_{net}}}}{{dx}} = 0$ , that is, the first derivative is kept equal to zero to find the extreme value of a function.
Using quotient formula we get,
$\dfrac{{d{F_{net}}}}{{dx}} = 4k{e^2}\dfrac{{\left( {1 \times {{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{3}{2}}} - \left( {x \times \dfrac{3}{2}{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{1}{2}}} \times 2x} \right)} \right)}}{{{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^3}}} \\ $
Putting this equal to zero, we get,
$4k{e^2}\dfrac{{\left( {1 \times {{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{3}{2}}} - \left( {x \times \dfrac{3}{2}{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{1}{2}}} \times 2x} \right)} \right)}}{{{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^3}}} = 0$
Simplifying this, we get,
$\left( {1 \times {{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{3}{2}}} - \left( {x \times \dfrac{3}{2}{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{1}{2}}} \times 2x} \right)} \right) = 0 \\ $
This implies,
$\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right){\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)^{\dfrac{1}{2}}} = 3{x^2}{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)^{\dfrac{1}{2}}} \\ $
Solving this, we get,
$\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right) = 3{x^2} \\ $
This gives, $2{x^2} = \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4} \\ $
Hence, $x = \pm \dfrac{b}{{2\sqrt 2 }}$
Thus, the $\alpha $ particle experience greatest force at a distance $x = \pm \dfrac{b}{{2\sqrt 2 }}$ from the foot of the perpendicular bisector of the line joining the nuclei of the two hydrogen atoms.
Hence, option B is the correct answer.
Note: Before doing this question one must know the rules of differentiation. Also, an important point to note in this question is that the direct expression of force between the $\alpha $ particle and a hydrogen atom is not the net force. We need to take into consideration the components of this force.
Formula Used:
Force between two charges,
$F = k\dfrac{{{q_1}{q_2}}}{{{r^2}}}$
where ${q_1}\,\& \,{q_2}$ are the two charges and $r$ is the distance between them.
Also, $k = \dfrac{1}{{4\pi { \in _o}}}$
Quotient formula of differentiation,
$\dfrac{d}{{dx}}\left( {\dfrac{{f\left( x \right)}}{{g\left( x \right)}}} \right) = \dfrac{{f'\left( x \right)g\left( x \right) - f\left( x \right)g'\left( x \right)}}{{{{\left( {g\left( x \right)} \right)}^2}}}$
Complete step by step solution:
Given: Charge on a hydrogen atom, ${q_1} = e$
Charge on the \[\alpha \] particles, ${q_2} = 2e$
Distance between the nuclei \[ = b\]
Let $F$ be the force between the \[\alpha \] particle and the hydrogen atom. Draw a perpendicular bisector of the line joining the nuclei of the two hydrogen atoms. Consider a point $P$ on it at a distance \[x\] from the foot of the perpendicular.

From the diagram above we can see that the vertical components of the force $F$ cancel each other. Hence, the net force becomes,
${F_{net}} = 2F\cos \theta $
Where $\cos \theta = \dfrac{x}{{{{\left( {{x^2} + {{\left( {\dfrac{b}{2}} \right)}^2}} \right)}^{\dfrac{1}{2}}}}}$
(denominator is obtained using Pythagoras theorem in $\vartriangle AOP$ )
This implies,
\[{F_{net}} = 2F\dfrac{x}{{{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{1}{2}}}}}\] ...(1)
Also,
$F = k\dfrac{{{q_1}{q_2}}}{{{r^2}}}$
That is,
$F = k\dfrac{{\left( e \right)\left( {2e} \right)}}{{{{\left( {{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{1}{2}}}} \right)}^2}}} \\ $...(2)
Substituting equation (2) in equation (1), we get,
\[{F_{net}} = 2\left( {k\dfrac{{\left( e \right)\left( {2e} \right)}}{{{{\left( {{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{1}{2}}}} \right)}^2}}}} \right)\dfrac{x}{{{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{1}{2}}}}} \\ \]
Simplifying this, we get,
\[{F_{net}} = \dfrac{{4kx{e^2}}}{{{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{3}{2}}}}}\]
Now, we know that the condition of extremum is: $\dfrac{{d{F_{net}}}}{{dx}} = 0$ , that is, the first derivative is kept equal to zero to find the extreme value of a function.
Using quotient formula we get,
$\dfrac{{d{F_{net}}}}{{dx}} = 4k{e^2}\dfrac{{\left( {1 \times {{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{3}{2}}} - \left( {x \times \dfrac{3}{2}{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{1}{2}}} \times 2x} \right)} \right)}}{{{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^3}}} \\ $
Putting this equal to zero, we get,
$4k{e^2}\dfrac{{\left( {1 \times {{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{3}{2}}} - \left( {x \times \dfrac{3}{2}{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{1}{2}}} \times 2x} \right)} \right)}}{{{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^3}}} = 0$
Simplifying this, we get,
$\left( {1 \times {{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{3}{2}}} - \left( {x \times \dfrac{3}{2}{{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)}^{\dfrac{1}{2}}} \times 2x} \right)} \right) = 0 \\ $
This implies,
$\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right){\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)^{\dfrac{1}{2}}} = 3{x^2}{\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right)^{\dfrac{1}{2}}} \\ $
Solving this, we get,
$\left( {{x^2} + \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4}} \right) = 3{x^2} \\ $
This gives, $2{x^2} = \dfrac{{{b^2}}}{4} \\ $
Hence, $x = \pm \dfrac{b}{{2\sqrt 2 }}$
Thus, the $\alpha $ particle experience greatest force at a distance $x = \pm \dfrac{b}{{2\sqrt 2 }}$ from the foot of the perpendicular bisector of the line joining the nuclei of the two hydrogen atoms.
Hence, option B is the correct answer.
Note: Before doing this question one must know the rules of differentiation. Also, an important point to note in this question is that the direct expression of force between the $\alpha $ particle and a hydrogen atom is not the net force. We need to take into consideration the components of this force.
Recently Updated Pages
Uniform Acceleration - Definition, Equation, Examples, and FAQs

JEE Main 2021 July 25 Shift 1 Question Paper with Answer Key

JEE Main 2021 July 22 Shift 2 Question Paper with Answer Key

JEE Atomic Structure and Chemical Bonding important Concepts and Tips

JEE Amino Acids and Peptides Important Concepts and Tips for Exam Preparation

JEE Electricity and Magnetism Important Concepts and Tips for Exam Preparation

Trending doubts
JEE Main 2025 Session 2: Application Form (Out), Exam Dates (Released), Eligibility, & More

Atomic Structure - Electrons, Protons, Neutrons and Atomic Models

Displacement-Time Graph and Velocity-Time Graph for JEE

JEE Main 2025: Derivation of Equation of Trajectory in Physics

Electric field due to uniformly charged sphere class 12 physics JEE_Main

Learn About Angle Of Deviation In Prism: JEE Main Physics 2025

Other Pages
JEE Advanced Marks vs Ranks 2025: Understanding Category-wise Qualifying Marks and Previous Year Cut-offs

Electric Field Due to Uniformly Charged Ring for JEE Main 2025 - Formula and Derivation

JEE Advanced Weightage 2025 Chapter-Wise for Physics, Maths and Chemistry

Charging and Discharging of Capacitor

Wheatstone Bridge for JEE Main Physics 2025

Instantaneous Velocity - Formula based Examples for JEE
