
Distinguish between coming together federations and holding together federations with example. India comes under which type of federation?
Answer
537.1k+ views
Hint:
Federalism is a form of government in which powers have been distributed between the central and its constituents, like provincial and local. Apart from a national government, jurisdiction is legally divided into two territorial levels, where the entities at each level have sole authority and may operate independently of the others in a given region. The constituent units have a certain degree of control depending on the form of federation.
Complete answer:
India's situation is drastically different from that of the United States, where states have mediated and a federation has been formed. The "unity and integrity of India" was the primary concern at the time of writing the Constitution. The main power is with the central government and rest autonomy with the state government. Thus, India comes under a federation.
Note:
Spain has an improper federation system. While highly decentralized, Spain is not a federation because the nation has reflected in the central government institutions that remain in full sovereignty. Each Autonomous Society shall be governed by a collection of institutions defined under its own Law of Sovereignty.
Federalism is a form of government in which powers have been distributed between the central and its constituents, like provincial and local. Apart from a national government, jurisdiction is legally divided into two territorial levels, where the entities at each level have sole authority and may operate independently of the others in a given region. The constituent units have a certain degree of control depending on the form of federation.
Complete answer:
| Coming together federation | Holding together federation |
| In this type of federation, separate sovereign states connect together to become a greater government. | In this type of federation, a broad force or country agrees to split its powers between the constituent states and the central government. |
| Individual States combine their sovereign rights and assets to form a stronger nation. | There is no pooling of authority and retention of nationality in such a federation. |
| In this federation, the individual states have sole authority. The ultimate result is a more stable nation. | In this federation, the central government has more authority than the states. |
| Examples are the USA, Australia, Switzerland | Examples are India, Spain, Belgium |
India's situation is drastically different from that of the United States, where states have mediated and a federation has been formed. The "unity and integrity of India" was the primary concern at the time of writing the Constitution. The main power is with the central government and rest autonomy with the state government. Thus, India comes under a federation.
Note:
Spain has an improper federation system. While highly decentralized, Spain is not a federation because the nation has reflected in the central government institutions that remain in full sovereignty. Each Autonomous Society shall be governed by a collection of institutions defined under its own Law of Sovereignty.
Recently Updated Pages
Master Class 10 English: Engaging Questions & Answers for Success

Master Class 10 Social Science: Engaging Questions & Answers for Success

Master Class 10 Computer Science: Engaging Questions & Answers for Success

Class 10 Question and Answer - Your Ultimate Solutions Guide

Master Class 10 General Knowledge: Engaging Questions & Answers for Success

Master Class 10 Maths: Engaging Questions & Answers for Success

Trending doubts
State and explain Ohms law class 10 physics CBSE

Distinguish between soap and detergent class 10 chemistry CBSE

a Why did Mendel choose pea plants for his experiments class 10 biology CBSE

What is a "free hit" awarded for in limited-overs cricket?

Draw the diagram of the sectional view of the human class 10 biology CBSE

Write a letter to the principal requesting him to grant class 10 english CBSE

